The Bluff

The Bluff falls into that strangely empty period of modern pop culture where pirates have become an amusement park memory: lots of nostalgia, but very few new ships actually leaving port. The mere fact that a pure, unadulterated swashbuckling film exists in 2026 could be a real event, and Frank E. Flowers (director and co-writer with Joe Ballarini) clearly knows what selling point he's using: a home invasion thriller in period costume, in the spirit of Die Hard on a Caribbean island, set against a backdrop of a quest for revenge and a heroine who isn't there to flirt with danger, but is herself the danger. Watching it, one can't help but think that the film is less interested in romanticizing piracy than in bringing it back to reality.

The beginning of the film quickly puts us in the right frame of mind: Captain Connor, played by Karl Urban, boards a ship commanded by T.H. Bodden, played by Ismael Cruz Córdova, and the film establishes its thesis with brutal efficiency: this is not the playful fantasy of pirates we have become accustomed to. When the story moves to Cayman Brac in 1846, the calm is almost suspicious: Ercell Bodden, played by Priyanka Chopra Jonas, is presented as a stable domestic presence, caring for her son Isaac, played by Vedanten Naidoo, and her sister-in-law Elizabeth, played by Safia Oakley-Green, in a community that seems to have built its tranquility with the sweat of its brow. And then the calm is broken. The best part of the beginning is the break-in sequence, where Ercell's apparent passivity resembles a performance within a performance: she plays the innocent until she stops doing so, and once the switch is made, the film suddenly takes off. The revelation isn't subtle (the script wants you to notice every change of pace), but the staging and physicality make the shock believable: this isn't a woman discovering her strength, it's a woman rediscovering skills she had forced herself not to use.

These skills are the real strength of the film, and this is where Priyanka Chopra Jonas deserves the title of action star in capital letters. There is a down-to-earth nastiness in the way Ercell fights, less balletic heroism, more tactical problem-solving, as if she were constantly scanning her environment for anything that could become a weapon or a trap. The choreography often favors close combat, and when the camera gives her the space she needs to execute her moves (rather than fragmenting them), you can feel the sweat and intention behind the violence. The most satisfying idea in the film is that Ercell doesn't win because she's stronger, but because she's smarter, meaner when she needs to be, and willing to use her patience as a weapon. Many action films treat brutality as a garnish; here, brutality is part of the texture: throats are slit, bodies fall horribly, and the film repeatedly reminds you that pirate life is essentially organized cruelty with better branding.

Where The Bluff falters is in everything that should connect these elements to make something that sticks in your memory. The screenplay by Frank E. Flowers and Joe Ballarini relies heavily on familiar genre tropes: the protective parent who is like a fortress, the helpless or stubborn dependent who exists to complicate escape plans, the villain who confuses obsession with depth. You get the feeling that the film regularly takes you aside to explain itself: flashbacks, expositions, and dialogues that try to sound meaningful but end up sounding repetitive. Worse still, some exchanges seem strangely light, as if the scenes had been assembled rather than lived; there are moments when the looks and editing give the impression that the actors are not sharing the same physical space, which is the kind of technical problem that can sabotage the tension in a story that is supposed to be immediate. The film also makes choices that undermine its own strengths: some action scenes are staged in subdued lighting that hides the choreography rather than highlighting it, and some backgrounds and climatic visual effects flirt with that “too clean to be real” digital sheen that takes the edge off an otherwise tactile premise.

Karl Urban is both an asset and a source of frustration in this context. He embodies a credible physical threat and knows how to play the role of a menacing pirate without falling into pantomime, but Captain Connor is written as a succession of sinister poses and sullen statements, and the film doesn't always give him the kind of active villainy that would justify this construction. When he can be direct, it works; when he is reduced to giving orders to his men and grumbling about what is his, the character begins to feel more like a concept than a person. The supporting roles, particularly Temuera Morrison as Lee, are terribly underutilized, while the family members (including Safia Oakley-Green and Vedanten Naidoo) are functional rather than fully dimensional: they matter because Ercell loves them, not because the script gives them enough specificity for you to perceive them as people beyond the stakes they represent.

Still, it can't be denied that the film does deliver a certain wicked, pulp-like satisfaction when it commits to being what it is: a chase for survival through the jungle, the river, the caves, and the eponymous cliff, complete with traps, improvised weapons, and that primitive pleasure of seeing a hunted character become the hunter. Traces of old-fashioned adventure spirit can be found in the production design and in the way the geography of Cayman Brac becomes a playground for violence, and even when the film veers into the ridiculous but amusing, Priyanka Chopra Jonas keeps it grounded with a performance that combines ferocity and control. The Bluff isn't the film that could have revived the pirate craze if it had focused as much on the characters as it did on the carnage, but as a streaming action movie, it's a solid, sometimes thrilling film that just needed a sharper script and clearer visual discipline to really stand out.

The Bluff
Directed by Frank E. Flowers
Written by Joe Ballarini, Frank E. Flowers
Produced by Joe Russo, Anthony Russo, Angela Russo-Otstot, Michael Disco, Priyanka Chopra Jonas, Cisely Saldana, Mariel Saldana
Starring Priyanka Chopra Jonas, Karl Urban, Ismael Cruz Córdova, Safia Oakley-Green, Temuera Morrison
Cinematography: Greg Baldi
Edited by Lisa Lassek
Music by Henry Jackman
Production companies: AGBO, Cinestar Pictures, Big Indie Pictures, Purple Pebble Pictures
Distributed by Amazon MGM Studios (via Prime Video)
Release dates: February 17, 2026 (TCL Chinese Theater), February 25, 2026 (Prime Video)
Running time: 101 minutes

Viewed on February 25, 2026 on Prime Video

Mulder's Mark: