Avatar: Fire and Ash

With Avatar: Fire and Ash, James Cameron once again plants his flag in the field he knows best: maximalist cinema, driven by conviction, spectacle, and an almost stubborn belief that movies should still be considered events. Clocking in at nearly three hours and seventeen minutes, the film is unapologetically monumental, demanding total immersion from the audience, without ever seeming flippant or sloppy. This is not about content, but about auteur cinema, shaped by a filmmaker who has spent decades refining a unique vision of Pandora, both a living ecosystem and a testing ground for cinematic experimentation. Sitting in a movie theater watching Avatar: Fire and Ash unfold, there is a palpable sense that James Cameron is less interested in a careful narrative economy than in immersion itself, in giving the audience the impression of being plunged into an ongoing myth rather than a carefully packaged sequel. This approach has its flaws (repetition, disjointed narration, moments of excessive candor), but it also gives rise to a film that feels huge, committed, and resolutely theatrical in an era increasingly dominated by disposable franchises.

Emotionally, the film is rooted in grief, and that grief permeates nearly every relationship within the Sully family. Jake Sully, played by Sam Worthington, behaves like a man who takes refuge in duty because his feelings have become unbearable, while Neytiri, played by Zoe Saldaña, channels her grief into devotion, anger, and barely contained resentment. The loss of their son Neteyam lingers like a wound that refuses to heal, shaping not only their choices but also the tone of the entire film. Lo'ak, played by Britain Dalton, emerges as a crucial emotional vehicle, weighed down by survivor's guilt and the feeling that his very existence is a reminder of what has been lost. James Cameron shifts here to a more intimate family drama, dealing with broken trust, generational burden, and the cost of leadership, but he rarely lets these ideas speak for themselves in silence. Instead, they are carried by movement, conflict, and escalation, reinforcing Cameron's belief that character is often revealed more clearly in moments of extreme pressure than in quiet reflection.

Structurally, Avatar: Fire and Ash undeniably echoes Avatar: The Way of Water, sometimes to a frustrating degree. The familiar rhythms of pursuit, capture, escape, and revenge are repeated so often that the film sometimes feels like it is going around in circles with its own mythology rather than advancing it. However, this repetition is offset by an expansion of Pandora's moral landscape, notably through the introduction of the Ash People. Led by Varang, played by Oona Chaplin, the Mangkwan clan represents a radical ideological break within Na'vi society, rejecting Eywa and embracing destruction as a strategy for survival. Varang is one of the most striking characters in the franchise, both visually and conceptually, her ash-covered presence and volcanic fury standing in stark contrast to the spiritual harmony traditionally associated with Pandora. Oona Chaplin brings a hypnotic physicality to the role, infusing Varang with menace, sensuality, and barely contained nihilism, even if the script ultimately sidelines her potential in favor of a more familiar antagonist dynamic.

This dynamic is further complicated by the return of Colonel Miles Quaritch, played by Stephen Lang, who remains the franchise's most perversely fascinating character. Fully integrated into his Na'vi body but clinging to his colonialist instincts, Colonel Miles Quaritch exists in a constant state of contradiction, and Avatar: Fire and Ash exploits this tension more openly than before. His unstable alliance with Varang crackles with a twisted chemistry, based on shared brutality and mutual fascination rather than ideology. Stephen Lang clearly relishes this role, giving Quaritch a strange vitality that borders on dark charisma, even if the character remains morally repugnant. In contrast, Spider, played by Jack Champion, occupies a more precarious narrative position, elevated to quasi-messianic importance while remaining emotionally underdeveloped. Spider's narrative arc drives the urgency of the plot, but the film struggles to reconcile its symbolic significance with the down-to-earth human perspective it is supposed to provide.

Visually, Avatar: Fire and Ash is stunning in a way that few modern blockbusters even dare to attempt. Russell Carpenter's cinematography, combined with James Cameron's ever-evolving motion capture technology, creates images so tactile that they become almost overwhelming. Fire-lit rituals, ash-covered battlefields, and dizzying aerial combat sequences are rendered with astonishing clarity and spatial coherence. James Cameron's mastery of large-scale action remains unmatched; even amid chaos, the geography is always legible, the movements always intentional. That said, the continued use of a high frame rate remains a double-edged sword, enhancing realism while sometimes breaking the illusion, reminding the viewer of the technological apparatus behind the dream. Nevertheless, when the film finds its rhythm, the result is pure cinematic transport, the kind that makes the outside world momentarily disappear.

Thematically, James Cameron, alongside Rick Jaffa and Amanda Silver, continues to favor clarity over nuance. Environmental collapse, colonial violence, faith versus fanaticism: these ideas are presented with the force of a manifesto rather than an essay. The metaphors are broad, the moral lines clearly drawn, and subtlety is rarely the goal. Yet there is an undeniable sincerity in Cameron's approach, a sense that he genuinely believes in the urgency of these messages and refuses to water them down for comfort's sake. In a cinematic landscape increasingly shaped by algorithmic caution, Avatar: Fire and Ash feels refreshing and unfiltered, even when its narrative bends under the weight of its own ambition.

It is impossible to write a review of Avatar: Fire and Ash without mentioning Simon Franglen's score, which is nothing short of remarkable. Drawing on the thematic foundations laid by James Horner, virtuoso composer Simon Franglen expands the musical language of Avatar with darker, more elemental textures that reflect the film's descent into conflict and ideological fracture. The score conveys an emotional charge that the dialogue sometimes cannot express, underscoring grief, wonder, and fury with remarkable sensitivity. In quieter moments, the music weeps with the characters; in action sequences, it surges with mythic force without overwhelming the images. It is a unifying element that binds the film's sprawling narrative, reinforcing Pandora's identity as both a sacred world and a battlefield, and is one of the most successful elements of the entire production.

Avatar: Fire and Ash is not the most coherent or disciplined film in the saga in terms of narrative, but it remains an impressive cinematic achievement. Despite all its excesses, repetitions, and indulgences, it offers moments of genuine wonder that reaffirm the power of theatrical spectacle. James Cameron may be revisiting familiar ground, but he does so with a scope, conviction, and sincerity that few living filmmakers can match. Flawed but formidable, overwhelming but undeniably immersive, Avatar: Fire and Ash won us over both with James Cameron's unparalleled mastery of blockbuster filmmaking and by reminding us that Pandora, for all its beauty, remains a world forged by conflict, faith, fire, and ashes.

Avatar: Fire and Ash
Directed by James Cameron
Written by James Cameron, Rick Jaffa, Amanda Silver
Story by James Cameron, Rick Jaffa, Amanda Silver, Josh Friedman, Shane Salerno
Produced by James Cameron, Jon Landau
Starring Sam Worthington, Zoe Saldaña, Sigourney Weaver, Stephen Lang, Kate Winslet
Cinematography: Russell Carpenter
Edited by Stephen E. Rivkin, David Brenner, Nicolas de Toth, John Refoua, Jason Gaudio, James Cameron
Music by Simon Franglen
Production Company: Lightstorm Entertainment
Distributed by: 20th Century Studios (United States), The Walt Disney Company France (France)
Release dates: December 1, 2025 (Dolby Theatre), December 17, 2025 (France), December 19, 2025 (United States)
Running time: 197 minutes

Seen on December 4, 2025 at La Seine Musicale

Mulder's Mark: