The Hand That Rocks the Cradle

The Hand That Rocks the Cradle (2025) is the kind of remake that reminds us how fragile nostalgia can be when it falls into the wrong hands. Directed by Michelle Garza Cervera and written by Micah Bloomberg, this new version of Curtis Hanson's 1992 family thriller attempts to modernize its premise by addressing themes of motherhood, homosexuality, and class anxiety, but ends up feeling hollow, drained of the suspense and bite of the original. Despite its brilliant cinematography and timely themes, this thriller confuses weight with depth, trading tension for boredom and replacing the pulp menace of the original with a laborious seriousness that never quite finds its tone.

The story follows Mary Elizabeth Winstead as Caitlin Morales, a Los Angeles lawyer and new mother whose carefully structured life begins to crack when she hires Polly Murphy (played by Maika Monroe), a troubled young woman she meets during a tenant rights consultation. What begins as a relationship of convenience—Caitlin needs help caring for her newborn and ten-year-old daughter; Polly needs a roof over her head—quickly turns into a psychological tug-of-war between two women bound by secrets, resentment, and a latent attraction that the film never dares to fully explore. Cervera hints at something richer beneath the surface—class jealousy, repressed desire, postpartum fragility—but never commits. The result feels like a half-baked thesis on motherhood disguised as a thriller that forgot how to thrill.

In Curtis Hanson's original, the horror came from the intersection of domestic trust and betrayal — the fear that the sanctuary of one's home could become hostile. Cervera's version seems indifferent to this fundamental tension. Instead, it aims for psychological realism, flattening the genre into a dull, prestigious aesthetic. The once-devious Peyton Flanders becomes Polly, whose motivations are concealed until the final act in a misguided attempt at mystery. By the time her tragic backstory is revealed—involving the orphanage and a burning house hinted at in a slow prologue—the suspense has long since evaporated. There is no sense of danger or revelation, just a superficial twist that leaves the viewer indifferent. Even Ariel Marx's haunting music fails to mask the monotony of the film's middle section, an endless loop of manipulative scenes where no one seems to learn or change.

Visually, Jo Willems' cinematography presents the Morales' house as a cold, sanitized glass box, with its clean lines and subdued lighting, but this immaculate environment never becomes the threatening playground it should be. The film confuses stillness with subtlety, lingering a little too long on shots and draining the scenes of their rhythm. The camera glides where it should leap. Even the violence, when it finally arrives, feels abrupt and obligatory—a severed hand here, a bloodied face there—without the cathartic release or dark humor that the genre once promised. The 1992 film may have been melodramatic, but it knew how to create terror; this one is content to wallow in gloom.

The performances, at least, attempt to rise above the script. Mary Elizabeth Winstead gives Caitlin an edge, capturing the fragile composure of a woman whose confidence in her own sanity is crumbling. Her exhaustion feels real, her outbursts painfully human. Yet she is undermined by a script that treats her mental state as plot device rather than point of view. Maika Monroe, meanwhile, has everything it takes to be a fascinating antagonist. Her character, Polly, is cold, calculating, and inscrutable, but too often misdirected by a film that confuses opacity with complexity. While Rebecca De Mornay, in the original, was serpentine and delightfully deranged, Monroe is so low-key that she becomes soporific. The tension between these two talented actresses should have been electric; instead, it flickers and fades, stifled by Cervera's slow pace.

There are moments when the film hints at relevant themes: a subplot about Caitlin's past relationship with a woman, a dinner scene where her daughter's coming out is misinterpreted as manipulation, a social commentary that contrasts the complacency of the privileged with financial insecurity. But these ideas remain unresolved, like unfinished thoughts. Nothing is coherent. Even Raúl Castillo, in the role of the well-meaning but oblivious husband, is written as a narrative accessory: a man so bland in his support that he becomes invisible. The removal of Curtis Hanson's handyman character, who once served as a moral compass and witness, robs the film of balance and depth.

 Each relationship exists in isolation, and the script's insistence on ambiguity only serves to diminish what little suspense remains. Ironically, Cervera's previous film, Huesera: The Bone Woman, possessed the qualities that are lacking here: fierce originality, a visceral understanding of maternal fear, and a willingness to let horror spill over from metaphor.

 That brutality is absent in The Hand That Rocks the Cradle (2025), where the director's instinct for the strange seems stifled by studio caution and algorithmic restraint. Hulu's version of “danger in domestic life” is sanitized, content to hint at peril while remaining well within the bounds of safe streaming content. The moral unease and pulp energy that once made the story compelling are gone, replaced by conscious gravity and overdetermined symbolism.

What remains is a film that aims to be both socially engaged and sensational, but ends up being neither. The singularity is timid, the class commentary superficial, the horror watered down. There is a vague suggestion that trauma reproduces itself—that wounded women wound women—but this is treated as a narrative afterthought rather than a guiding principle. By the time the credits roll, what lingers is neither fear nor pity, but indifference. The cradle may still rock, but this time, it lulls you to sleep.

For all its ambition, The Hand That Rocks the Cradle (2025) is a remake that misses what made its predecessor so successful: the willingness to embrace its own absurdity. Curtis Hanson's film may have been pulp and outdated, but it had conviction—it believed in its own nightmare. Garza Cervera's version, on the other hand, seems embarrassed by its genre, disguising it as an arthouse psychological drama and erasing all the dangerous aspects. What remains is a beautifully filmed, competently performed, but emotionally empty echo of a once provocative story. A film that doesn't so much rock the cradle as doze quietly beside it.

The Hand That Rocks the Cradle
Directed by Michelle Garza Cervera
Written by Micah Bloomberg
Based on The Hand That Rocks the Cradle by Amanda Silver
Produced by Ted Field, Michael Schaefer, Mike Larocca
Starring Mary Elizabeth Winstead, Maika Monroe, Raúl Castillo, Martin Starr
Director of photography: Jo Willems
Editing: Julie Monroe
Music: Ariel Marx
Production companies: 20th Century Studios, Department M, Radar Pictures
Distributed by Hulu (United States), Disney+ (France)
Release date: October 22, 2025 (United States), November 19, 2025 (France)
Running time: 105 minutes

Seen on October 23, 2025

Mulder's Mark: