The Red Mask

The Red Mask, directed by Ritesh Gupta and written by Samantha Gurash and Patrick Robert Young, is the kind of horror movie that knows exactly what it's doing: it looks straight into the bloodshot eyes of its genre and asks, “Where do we go from here?” The film opens with Helena Howard as Allina Green, a Black queer screenwriter who is given the delicate task of reviving a classic 1980s gore film. Her job is to reimagine The Red Mask, a cult 1982 film featuring a home invasion bloodbath, which has long since fallen into obscurity. But Allina Green's dilemma—how to respect the roots of horror without reproducing its outdated clichés—becomes the dilemma of the film itself. In Ritesh Gupta's writing, this conflict is not only thematic but also structural: the film constantly oscillates between homage and critique, a dance of knives that cuts through decades of horror history while keeping an eye on the bruised ego of the present.

It is ironic that Allina Green's creative paralysis stems precisely from the community that claims to love horror the most. A few online detractors, rabid fans who accuse her of being woke, unleash a storm of death threats, forcing her to take refuge in a remote cabin in the woods with her fiancée Deetz, played with incisive warmth by Inanna Sarkis. The irony is lost on no one familiar with today's fan wars: how the genre that once gave voice to outsiders now often turns on itself. In that cabin, the boundaries blur—between fantasy and reality, acting and real fear—as the couple writes according to the franchise's scene method, Deetz donning the eponymous red mask while Allina attempts to overcome her writer's block. When a double booking brings in another couple, Ryan (Jake Abel) and Claire (Kelli Garner), the calm becomes predatory. What begins as a creative experiment turns into a bloody therapy session on fatherhood, property, and identity.

Ritesh Gupta orchestrates it all with mischievous precision. His camera lingers less on the gore than on the tension, the kind that comes from watching people intellectualize horror until it strikes back. It's as much a play as it is a slasher, and its best moments come not from the murders but from the conversations: long debates about what horror should be, whether Funny Games was moral or manipulative, whether Scream saved or strangled the genre. These scenes could have fallen flat in less skilled hands, but the actors sell them as both meta-commentary and emotional confessions. Ryan, played by Jake Abel, represents the possessive nostalgia of the old-school fanboy, the type who reveres the fundamental principles of slasher purity. Helena Howard, meanwhile, infuses her intellectualism with vulnerability: her performance crackles with the exhaustion of someone trying to create something new in a space that punishes difference.

The brilliant idea behind The Red Mask lies in the way it uses this creative impasse as a narrative engine. Like Wes Craven's New Nightmare or Scream, it is both the knife and the mirror. Samantha Gurash and Patrick Robert Young's screenplay incorporates references to Barbarian, Bone Lake, and even the debates about elevated horror that have divided audiences in recent years. But what makes it resonate is the emotional current that underlies its intelligence: this is not a film that mocks fans, but one that laments what they have become. There is a painful authenticity in its depiction of online virulence, in the way anonymous users wield nostalgia as a weapon to control art. The horror here comes not only from masked killers, but from the fragility of creation when every gesture is publicly dissected.

Even if The Red Mask sometimes overuses its twists and turns, its final act rewards its ambition. When the blood finally flows, it feels deserved, not as spectacle, but as metaphor, as if the film itself must kill its own discourse in order to be reborn. Ritesh Gupta delivers a confident and cerebral debut that proves horror doesn't have to choose between the primitive and the political. It can be both at once: a machete and a mirror. For viewers willing to meet it halfway, The Red Mask is not just a slasher reboot, it's an autopsy of the genre's soul, and a reminder that behind every mask, there is someone desperately trying to tell their story before someone else silences them.

The Red Mask
Directed by Ritesh Gupta
Written by Samantha Gurash, Patrick Robert Young
Produced by Kearin Coonan, Stephen McFarlane, Blaine Morris, Max Neace, Jayson Ramos, Isen Robbins, Aimee Schoof, Atit Shah, Deepen Shah
Starring Kelli Garner, Jake Abel, Inanna Sarkis, Teddy Moutinho, Helena Howard, James A. Janisse, Chelsea Rebecca, Sam Morgan, Rachel Paulson, Carly King, Shaylaren Hilton, Mykie, Tiffany Huber, Kayleen Casey, Megan Anderson, Joey Millin, Zoe Annabel, Jeremy Ray Burchard, Tia Hysonk, Matthew Torres
Cinematography: Powell Robinson
Edited by Jacquelyn Le, Tuan Quoc Le
Production companies: Create Entertainment, Intrinsic Value Films
Release dates: TBD
Running time: 91 minutes

Viewed on October 8, 2025 (Screamfest 2025 press screener)

Mulder's Mark: