Appofeniacs

Appofeniacs, directed by Chris Marrs Piliero, is both a wild experiment in the genre and an uncompromising mirror held up to our chaotic digital reality. The title itself, taken from the term apophenia (the human tendency to perceive patterns and connections where there are none), already hints at the paranoia, misinformation, and misplaced vengeance that permeate the film. Chris Marrs Piliero, best known for his music videos, makes his film debut with a work that resembles a collision between Quentin Tarantino's Pulp Fiction and a particularly vicious episode of Black Mirror. The result is messy, deliberately provocative, and undeniably entertaining, even if it risks collapsing under the weight of its own fractured structure.

The film wastes no time in establishing its thesis. A man named James (played by Chad Addison) discovers what he believes to be a pornographic video of his girlfriend Ali (played by Scarlett DeMeo) and her friend Chase (Amogh Kapoor). Overcome with rage, James murders Ali, but we later learn that the video is a deepfake created by Duke (Aaron Holliday), a petty and vengeful incel who has made it his hobby to fabricate digital lies to torment those around him. Duke's smug demonstration of this app to Cedrick (Jermaine Fowler) is both comical and frightening: “It's already in the wrong hands, because it's in our hands,” he quips, embodying the kind of destructive arrogance that seems straight out of an online troll forum. This opening lays bare the film's underlying anxiety: reality is increasingly fragile, and with the right touches, lives can be destroyed in minutes.

From there, Chris Marrs Piliero scatters us across several overlapping plots, each set in motion by Duke's reckless manipulations. We meet Texas Tim (Will Brandt), a well-meaning Uber driver whose ride with Poppy (Simran Jehani) plunges him into a bizarre desert gathering that degenerates into violence after a doctored video is released. There's Clinto Binto (Sean Gunn), a cosplay craftsman whose replica weapons are more threatening than intended, and Lazzy (Paige Searcy), a young store clerk whose life falls apart after a viral video casts her as the villain in a routine argument. The stories blend together like ink in water, with each small encounter having catastrophic consequences. Chris Marrs Piliero borrows Quentin Tarantino's interwoven narrative style, even sprinkling the dialogue with references to the DVD Django Unchained, but unlike a simple homage, the director exploits this structure to amplify the paranoia of a world where nothing—image, word, or memory—can be considered reliable.

What makes Appofeniacs resonate beyond its gore is its almost prophetic sense of timing. Watching Duke happily distort reality to his advantage, it's hard not to recall recent headlines about celebrities such as Taylor Swift falling victim to deepfake pornography, or the rising tide of synthetic misinformation that spreads faster than corrections ever can. The genius of Chris Marrs Piliero's approach lies not in presenting a dystopian future, but in suggesting that we are already there. One anecdote that has stuck with me since seeing the film involves a scene with superglue, an everyday object turned into a grotesque instrument of torture, which made much of the audience wince. The effect was visceral, reminding us how mundane tools, in the wrong hands, can become monstrous. The same could be said of the smartphones we all carry around with us.

In terms of performance, the ensemble flourishes under Piliero's gonzo vision. Aaron Holliday perfectly embodies Duke's mix of arrogance and pathetic fragility, a character who could be considered a mere comic foil if he didn't leave a trail of corpses in his wake. Jermaine Fowler plays Cedrick with a sly edge, an opportunist who is half horrified but still tempted by Duke's technological tricks. Simran Jehani brings flamboyant unpredictability to Poppy, while Sean Gunn relishes his role as a cosplay creator, giving the film its most bizarrely humorous moments. But it's perhaps Paige Searcy who stands out the most, her character shifting from irritation to sympathy to tragedy, encapsulating the film's commentary on how quickly public opinion swings in the age of viral videos.

Stylistically, Appofeniacs bears the hallmarks of Chris Marrs Piliero's music videos: neon hues, frenetic editing, and a pace that often feels like you're immersed in the middle of a song. At times, this energy works wonders, particularly during the murder sequences, which are staged with a sure knack for grotesque shock and dark comedy. A final scene involving Clinto Binto replicas is as absurd as it is horrifying, pushing the limits of special effects in a way that had the Fantastic Fest audience laughing and gasping. Yet this same kinetic style sometimes works against the film. The first act, populated by characters who seem straight out of Clerks or Mallrats, drags on before the real carnage begins, and the incessant narrative twists and turns can make the film feel more like an anthology than a coherent whole.

Still, there's something admirable about Chris Marrs Piliero's willingness to push Appofeniacs into such chaotic territory. The film understands that the real horror of deepfakes isn't the technology itself, but the people who use it without regard for the consequences. The characters in Appofeniacs are selfish, flawed, and often ridiculous, but they don't deserve the nightmare that is inflicted upon them, an irony that amplifies the terror. By the time the final act descends into bloody madness, with cosplay swords slicing flesh and adhesive glue becoming a weapon of war, the audience is ready to see this digital nightmare not as fantasy, but as a disturbing and plausible extension of our everyday lives.

Appofeniacs is not a perfect film. Its plot is overloaded, its influences sometimes too obvious, and its structure uneven. Yet for a debut film, it is bold, provocative, and resolutely rooted in its time. Chris Marrs Piliero may not be saying anything revolutionary about artificial intelligence, but the sheer audacity of his narrative makes his warning impossible to ignore. In a world where manipulated images can trigger bloodshed in reality, Appofeniacs forces us to face an uncomfortable truth: reality is already blurred, and we may be the ones holding the match that will set it alight.

Appofeniacs
Written and directed by Chris Marrs Piliero
Produced by Jared Iacino, Andrew Panay, Chris Marrs Piliero
Starring Aaron Holliday, Alfonso Caballero, Amogh Kapoor, Brendan Clifford, Chad Addison, Chris Marrs Piliero, David Pressman, E.R. Ruiz, Harley Bronwyn, Jermaine Fowler, Kevin Bohleber, Lisa Costanza, Massi Pregoni, Michael Abbott Jr., Paige Searcy, Scarlett DeMeo, Sean Gunn, Simran Jehani, Will Brandt, Zelda Gay
Cinematography: Adam Leene
Running time: 90 minutes

Seen on September 21, 2025 (press screener Fantastic Fest 2025)

Mulder's Mark: