Sovereign

Sovereign, the debut feature from writer-director Christian Swegal, arrives as both a devastating true-crime drama and a mirror held up to the fractures of contemporary America. Drawing on the real-life tragedy of Jerry Kane and his teenage son Joe Kane, the film eschews sensationalist thrills in favor of an unflinching exploration of desperation, belief, and the way fathers imprint their broken ideals on their children. What emerges is less an action thriller than a modern American tragedy, one that plays out across shabby motels, foreclosure notices, and small-town police stations, but whose echoes reach into the political divisions and economic despair of today.

The film opens with the stark sound of a 911 call — panic, gunfire, two officers dead. Rather than plunging immediately into violence, Christian Swegal rewinds the tape, taking us back to the weeks leading to that outcome. This framing choice turns the entire narrative into a slow-motion car crash, where dread accumulates with each scene. We first meet Joe Kane, played with fragile melancholy by Jacob Tremblay, alone in a decaying Arkansas home, receiving yet another foreclosure notice. It is a cruelly ordinary detail — a stack of papers demanding payments that will never be made — and it anchors the film in the fallout of the 2008 financial collapse. From the start, Sovereign makes clear that the “sovereign citizen” ideology does not emerge in a vacuum; it festers in economic ruin, isolation, and a culture that leaves its most vulnerable to fend for themselves.

Enter Jerry Kane, embodied with extraordinary depth by Nick Offerman. Long known to audiences for the comedic libertarian bravado of Ron Swanson, Nick Offerman delivers here the performance of his career, shedding irony to reveal the wounded humanity inside extremism. Jerry is no cartoon villain. He is a widower, a failed roofer, a man hollowed by grief and debt, yet also a father who insists he loves his son. His methods are desperate, his ideology incoherent, but Nick Offerman imbues him with a bruised sincerity that makes his descent all the more chilling. When Jerry tells Joe that “receiving is a choice” — dismissing foreclosure papers as if they hold no power — it is both absurd and heartbreaking. Nick Offerman convinces us that Jerry believes his own rhetoric, even as it spirals into paranoia and violence.

The film meticulously charts this spiral. Jerry takes Joe on the road, dressing them both in matching white suits and red ties like a two-man ministry, touring small towns where desperate citizens pay cash to hear Jerry’s gospel of loopholes and resistance. These scenes, echoing revival meetings and pyramid schemes alike, are at once grotesque and deeply sad. The people in those rooms have lost homes, jobs, dignity — they are easy prey for promises of sovereignty. Watching Joe collect crumpled bills from attendees while eyeing the world he is barred from joining — the neighbor girl he spies on Facebook, the classrooms he is denied — captures the tragedy of a childhood sacrificed to ideology.

Running parallel is the story of Chief John Bouchart, played with grizzled authority by Dennis Quaid, and his son Adam, a new police officer portrayed by Thomas Mann. These father-son dynamics form the film’s backbone: Jerry and Joe, John and Adam, each relationship rigidly shaped by patriarchy, discipline, and duty. Bouchart instructs his son to let his newborn “cry it out” rather than pick him up, convinced that toughness is love. Jerry tells Joe that freedom lies in rejecting every law and authority, even as he drags him toward destruction. The symmetry is striking: both fathers teach lessons that risk crippling the next generation, and both sons carry the burden of choices they did not make. Christian Swegal wisely avoids neat parallels or easy moralizing; instead, he suggests that toxic masculinity, whether wrapped in a badge or a white suit, shapes lives with equally devastating weight.

It would be easy for Sovereign to caricature Jerry as a cult leader or conman. Instead, Christian Swegal frames him as a man broken by systems too vast to fight, clinging to conspiracy because it offers coherence in a world that has denied him control. The film doesn’t excuse him — far from it — but it demands we understand the soil that grows extremism. When Jerry recalls the death of his infant daughter and the government-mandated autopsy that, in his mind, violated his parental rights, Nick Offerman’s raw grief makes us see how personal tragedy calcified into ideology. His rants about banks and bureaucracy may be riddled with pseudo-legal nonsense, but beneath them lies the universal howl of a man who feels unseen, unheard, discarded.

The supporting cast enriches the film’s texture. Jacob Tremblay, whose career has been defined by roles as victimized children, plays Joe with haunting restraint. His hunched shoulders, hesitant glances, and rare bursts of defiance make him the film’s emotional anchor. He is both indoctrinated disciple and silent skeptic, torn between filial love and a yearning for normalcy. Martha Plimpton shines in her brief but crucial role as Lesley Anne, a woman drawn into Jerry’s orbit, who sees in him both a savior and a grifter. Her presence offers Joe a fleeting glimpse of maternal care, a reminder of what has been lost. Thomas Mann brings a gentle decency to Adam, contrasting sharply with his father’s rigidity, while Dennis Quaid gives Bouchart a weary gravitas that conveys both authority and emotional repression.

Stylistically, Sovereign is deliberately restrained. Dustin Lane’s cinematography captures the muted landscapes of rural America — empty highways, strip malls, dingy motels — a visual monotony that underscores the banality of despair. James McAlister’s score, often relying on hushed tones and wordless vocals, heightens the tension without melodrama. Christian Swegal trusts his actors, often holding on silences or close-ups that reveal more than any speech could. The result is a film that feels lived-in, textured, and disturbingly plausible.

What elevates Sovereign beyond most true-crime dramas is its refusal to sensationalize or to take sides. It acknowledges the danger of Jerry’s movement while also recognizing the systemic failures that gave it oxygen. It critiques law enforcement’s rigidity without painting them as villains. Most importantly, it frames fatherhood — the lessons passed, the wounds inherited — as the central tragedy. What are sons taught, and to what end? The film’s climax, inevitable yet wrenching, lands not because of shock but because every step leading to it felt unavoidable. It is the slow drowning of men trapped by their own beliefs, pulling their children under with them.

At its core, Sovereign is a story about America — about economic collapse, toxic masculinity, the lure of conspiracy, and the aching need to belong. It is also a story about how love, when warped by ideology, can become indistinguishable from violence. Nick Offerman, Jacob Tremblay, and Dennis Quaid deliver some of the finest work of their careers, while Christian Swegal announces himself as a filmmaker of striking empathy and restraint. The film is unsettling, thought-provoking, and devastating, a work that lingers like an unanswered question. In the end, Sovereign is less about the Kanes themselves than about the culture that made them possible — and the sobering truth that such tragedies are not relics of the past but warnings of the present.

Sovereign
Written and directed by Christian Swegal
Produced by Nick Moceri
Starring  Nick Offerman, Jacob Tremblay, Thomas Mann, Nancy Travis, Martha Plimpton, Dennis Quaid
Cinematography : Dustin Lane
Edited by David Henry
Music by James McAlister
Production company : All Night Diner
Distributed by Briarcliff Entertainment ((United States)
Release dates : June 8, 2025 (Tribeca), July 11, 2025 (US)
Running time : 100 minutes

Seen on September 7 2025 at the Deauville International Center

Mulder's Mark: