The Arbiter

In recent years, British independent cinema has proven to be fertile ground for filmmakers who rely more on creativity and daring than on huge budgets. Marc Price, who first came to prominence at FrightFest in 2009 with his now legendary zombie film Colin, made on a budget of £50, has built his career by making the most of limited resources to create original and surprising visions. With The Arbiter, his latest and most ambitious project to date, he once again reaffirms his place among the most daring voices in low-budget genre cinema. Moving away from the realistic science fiction of Dune Drifter and revisiting the high-octane chaos of his underrated film Nightshooters, Marc Price delivers a gangster thriller that draws on Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels, The Warriors, and a feverish post-apocalyptic nightmare.

The result is a film that embraces its eccentricity, celebrates its absurdity, and pushes the conventions of British gangster films in new and unpredictable directions. At the center of the story is Verril, “the Arbiter,” played with a mix of weary gravity and sarcastic irony by Craig Russell, a longtime collaborator of Marc Price and a familiar face at genre film festivals.

Verril is the only one who can negotiate peace between rival gangs, an almost mythical character who embodies both the futility and necessity of order in a world based on chaos. London, though never explicitly named, becomes a lawless battleground where gangs rule according to an unspoken code: violence is tolerated, but only until guns and excessive destruction come into play. This fragile balance is shattered by the Nightcrawlers, a masked gang of anarchic madmen determined to dominate all others, forcing Verril to bring the rival factions together in a ruined, booby-trapped building to negotiate a truce under the watchful eye of a police representative, played with subtle authority by Ekow Quartey.

The genius of The Arbiter lies in its gallery of grotesque and colorful characters, each a walking contradiction between menace and absurdity. Among this gallery of thugs are Alastair Kirton as Guy, a pyromaniac obsessed with fire who seems to take an almost poetic pleasure in destruction; Georgina Leonidas as Terry, a ruthless ice cream magnate whose sweet business contrasts hilariously with her violent instincts; Jasmine Sumner as Rusty, a roller skater whose skates are as deadly as any blade; Jon Xue Zhang as Stuart, a parkour-trained martial artist who is more agile than sane; and Michael Geary as Henry, a paranoid tech genius constantly on the verge of a nervous breakdown. Each faction is so stylized that audiences can't help but pick their favorites, whether it's rooting for the ice cream cartel or laughing at the roller-skating assassins.

This kaleidoscope of gangs sets The Arbiter apart from more interchangeable depictions of British crime syndicates, giving the film an energy closer to comic book surrealism than social realism. That said, The Arbiter is not without its structural challenges. The film opens with tremendous momentum: Craig Russell's opening monologue, superimposed over a montage of urban decay and street violence, immediately sets the stage with verve and clarity.

But after this energetic introduction, the narrative focuses on the claustrophobic setting of the summit meeting, where rival gangs argue, size each other up, and eventually descend into betrayal and violence. While this “film in a bottle” approach allows Marc Price to stretch the budget and focus on the tensions created by the dialogue, it also slows down the pace, leaving the audience waiting for the frenetic momentum promised at the beginning. The transition between frenetic bursts of action and long sequences of verbal jousting can sometimes feel uneven, creating a rhythm that is both captivating and frustrating. Yet this dissonance is also part of the film's charm: it never falls into a predictable rhythm, forcing the viewer to remain alert and expect the unexpected.

Technically, The Arbiter shines with its inventiveness. The fight choreography, while never reaching the operatic brutality of Gangs of London, is disjointed, kinetic, and punctuated with clever practical effects that make the most of the film's modest means. The explosions, knife fights, and hand-to-hand combat are staged with a raw physicality that feels refreshing and unpolished, bringing an immediacy that is often lacking in more sanitized action films. And then there's the humor, a typically British, almost absurd touch that defuses the tension at key moments. Whether it's gang members pausing in the middle of a fight to discuss congenital heart disease or the revelation that terrifying masked killers have mundane names like “Christopher,” the comedy prevents the violence from descending into nihilism and instead presents the chaos as a grotesque carnival of human madness.

Despite these strengths, the film struggles to develop its characters, particularly in its treatment of Verril. The audience is clearly meant to identify with Craig Russell's Arbiter, a man wounded by his past and tasked with the impossible job of maintaining order in a world in ruins. But his narrative arc never seems to come to fruition, leaving him more of an enigmatic character than a fully-fledged protagonist. Similarly, while the cast offers a wealth of eccentricity, the characters' trajectories are static; we see them clash, joke, and fight, but they rarely evolve. This is perhaps The Arbiter's greatest limitation: its spectacle and humor are undeniable, but its emotional resonance remains superficial.

Still, The Arbiter is a bold experiment that pays homage to British gangster films and American cult classics. It's hard not to smile at the cheeky nods to Walter Hill's Streets of Fire and The Warriors, or at the sense that Marc Price is deliberately playing with clichés to expose their absurdity. In many ways, the film seems tailor-made for late-night festival screenings, where audiences can laugh, cheer, and root for their favorite side. It may not reinvent the wheel, but it embraces its own eccentricities with such conviction that it's hard not to get carried away.

Looking at Marc Price's trajectory, from the 50-pound miracle of Colin to the stylized chaos of The Arbiter, we see a filmmaker who refuses to play it safe, who always finds a way to expand the scope of his imagination, regardless of budget constraints. While The Arbiter may lack the emotional depth or narrative rigor of the best films in the genre, it makes up for it with personality, humor, and a fearless acceptance of excess. This is a film to be enjoyed for what it is: a loud, bloody, and eccentric escapade into gang-ridden London, staged with the unbridled energy of a filmmaker who knows how to turn limitations into opportunities.

The Arbiter
Written and directed by Marc Price
Produced by Michael Geary, Michelle Parkyn
Starring Craig Russell, Ekow Quartey, Georgina Leonidas, Jon Xue Zhang, Alastair Kirton, Jasmine Sumner, Michael Geary, James Groom, Claudia Gregory, Zoe Purdy, Nad Abdoolakhan, Sean Bingham, Kyle Davies, Phil Deguara, Asher Green, Les Kenny-Green, Oliver Malam, Michael Matucci, Tony McGregor, Angela Peters, Richard Sandling
Cinematography: Richard Jackson
Music by Kati Falk-Flores
Production companies: Dead Pixel Productions, Stardom Films
Release dates: TBD
Running time: 109 minutes

Viewed on August 20, 2025 (Frightfest press screener)

Mulder's Mark: