Peter Pan's Neverland Nightmare

When J. M. Barrie first introduced Peter Pan to the world, he created a character who thrived on the fantastical idea of eternal youth, free from the responsibilities of adulthood. Yet beneath the charm of this flying prankster lurked something far more unsettling: a character who takes children away into the night and never returns. The idea of Peter Pan as a horror villain is not really new; it has always been embedded in the DNA of the original story. So when Scott Chambers tried to reinvent the classic character in Peter Pan's Neverland Nightmare, the real surprise was not that the story had been turned into a horror movie, but that it had taken so long for someone to take on such an adaptation.

The idea of transforming childhood classics into horror nightmares has grown in popularity in recent years, but Peter Pan's Neverland Nightmare stands out by taking its dark concept seriously and creating an experience that is both unsettling and unexpected. Instead of simply capitalizing on a public domain character to create a shock effect, director and screenwriter Scott Chambers attempts to weave a narrative that explores the nature of lost innocence, trauma and the dangers lurking in the shadows of the child's imagination. Although imperfect, the film is an intriguing and ambitious entry into the Twisted Childhood universe, with enough style and disturbing creativity to keep the audience interested.

The story follows Michael Darling (Peter DeSouza-Feighoney), a quiet boy who becomes the latest victim of Peter Pan (Martin Portlock), a deranged circus performer turned child abductor who roams the English countryside in a van marked “Go to Neverland”. Gone are the fanciful flights to a magical world; in their place is a dark reality where Peter is less a childlike adventurer than a scarred lunatic, addicted to heroin, with a penchant for kidnapping and murder. When Michael's older sister Wendy (Megan Placito) embarks on a desperate mission to save him, the film presents itself as a standard slasher with a grubby aesthetic and increasingly brutal murders.

What sets Neverland Nightmare apart from other similar horror adaptations is the emphasis on its ominous atmosphere. The director of photography makes excellent use of shadows, evoking a sense of claustrophobic terror, while the eerie soundtrack amplifies the tension. Scott Chambers does an impressive job of creating a nightmarish world where the boundaries between fantasy and reality blur. The production design, particularly Peter's lair, is grotesquely fascinating, filled with disturbing drawings of Neverland and the decaying remains of past victims. There is a certain artistry in the way the film constructs its horror, preventing it from looking like a simple commercial operation.

Martin Portlock's portrayal of Peter Pan is another highlight of this movie. Rather than playing him as a simple slasher villain, he imbues Peter with an unsettling sense of duality, a mixture of childlike wonder and deranged menace. He injects himself with fairy dust (a heroin-like drug) to maintain his illusions, a concept that could have been frightening but ultimately seems like a smoke screen. His motivations remain frustratingly unclear: does he really believe in Neverland or is it simply a grotesque metaphor for his crimes? The movie never provides a definitive answer, but Portlock's performance adds enough disturbing unpredictability to make Peter a compelling antagonist.

Perhaps the most fascinating reinvention is that of Tinkerbell (Kit Green), who is portrayed as a drug addict victim of Peter, barely clinging to reality. Her tragic story adds an unexpected emotional layer to the film, making it one of the most intriguing elements. Although the character is not fully developed, the idea of a fairy reduced to a desperate and broken character, trapped in Peter's twisted world, is undeniably haunting.

The structure of the film does not always do it justice. The first act gets off to a strong start, presenting Peter as a terrifying character who lurks in the shadows of children's bedrooms like a real bogeyman. The opening sequence, where he emerges from a trapdoor to abduct a child, is genuinely disturbing and reminds us of a cult scene from the movie Child's Play. But as the story progresses, the tension dissipates in favor of repetitive murders and a bloated movie milieu that struggles to gain momentum. Wendy's investigation into her brother's disappearance should be the emotional core of the movie, but instead it feels like a series of loosely connected scenes that never lead to anything meaningful.

That's not to say that the film is without merit in its second half. Some of its most visually arresting moments appear in the final act, including a disturbing sequence in which Peter forces Michael to prepare for Neverland in increasingly terrifying ways. There's also a particularly brutal murder sequence on a school bus which, although gratuitous, is one of the few times the movie fully engages in its slasher roots. On the contrary, Neverland Nightmare could have benefited from these wild and unhinged scenes instead of dragging its feet in slower scenes.

Despite its flaws, Peter Pan's Neverland Nightmare is far from the disaster many expected it to be. Admittedly, the pace is difficult to follow and, at times, it feels like the movie wants to be two different horror movies at once, but when it works, it really works. The world of twisted childhood is still in its infancy, but if this movie is any indication, the franchise has the potential to become something more substantial. This movie stands out for its moments of grotesque creativity and nightmarish world-building. It may not reinvent the horror genre, but it is certainly an ambitious and daring take on a childhood classic.

If you are a fan of twisted fairy tales, unsettling horror aesthetics and theatrical slasher villains, Peter Pan's Neverland Nightmare is well worth a look. It's a step up from the more amateurish entries in the Twisted Childhood universe, and while it doesn't quite deliver on all its promises, it does offer enough eerie atmosphere and disturbing imagery to make for a fascinating, if imperfect, horror experience. If nothing else, it proves that Peter Pan has always been a little more terrifying than we thought.

Peter Pan's Neverland Nightmare
Written and Directed by Scott Chambers
Based on Peter Pan by J. M. Barrie
Produced by Rhys Frake-Waterfield, Scott Jeffrey
Starring Martin Portlock, Megan Placito, Kit Green, Peter DeSouza-Feighoney, Charity Kase, Teresa Banham, Nicholas Woodeson, Kierston Wareing, Olumide Olorunfemi
Cinematography: Vince Knight
Edited by Dan Allen
Music by Greg Birkumshaw
Production company: Jagged Edge Productions
Distributed by Iconic Events Releasing (United States)
Release dates: January 13, 2025 (United States), February 24, 2025 (United Kingdom)
Running time: 89 minutes

Seen on January 14, 2025 (press screener)

Mulder's Mark: