A real Pain

Jesse Eisenberg's A Real Pain is a cinematic plunge into generational trauma, family ties and the lingering effects of historical atrocities. As writer and director, Jesse Eisenberg balances dark humor and poignant emotion, creating a rich narrative that feels deeply personal yet has universal resonance. This film is not simply an exploration of Jewish identity; it's a meditation on the scars of history and how they intertwine with the more mundane struggles of modern life. Anchored by Kieran Culkin's magnetic performance as Benji Kaplan and Jesse Eisenberg's understated yet profoundly effective performance as David Kaplan, the film captures the bittersweet essence of human connection in the midst of shared pain.

Benji and David, cousins born within weeks of each other but emotionally estranged, embark on a trip to Poland to honor the memory of their recently deceased grandmother, a Holocaust survivor. The trip, which appears to be a way of reconnecting with their roots, becomes a crucible for their strained relationship. David, a man defined by his neuroses and meticulous planning, contrasts sharply with Benji, whose manic charisma and emotional volatility mask a deep inner turmoil. The film opens with an airport scene in which these personality conflicts are immediately brought to the surface. Benji's effortless charm and chaos clash magnificently with David's uptight attitude, setting the stage for the unfolding drama.

The narrative framework of a Holocaust tour may seem heavy-handed, but Eisenberg's script deftly interweaves moments of levity and absurdity without ever undermining the gravity of the historical backdrop. The ensemble of tourists adds texture and depth, especially thanks to characters like the introspective Eloge, a survivor of the Rwandan genocide played with quiet strength by Kurt Egyiawan, and the kindly reflective Marcia, played by Jennifer Grey. Each member of the group brings his or her own baggage, but it's through Benji's interactions that the film's themes of guilt, privilege and the yearning for catharsis crystallize.

The character Benji is a whirlwind of contradictions. His quick-witted humor and reckless behavior serve both as a defense mechanism and a cry for help. Whether orchestrating a bizarre photo shoot at the Warsaw Uprising monument or denouncing the privilege inherent in modern Holocaust tourism, Benji's antics oscillate between endearing and infuriating. Yet Kieran Culkin imbues the character with such raw vulnerability that even his most extravagant outbursts are heartbreakingly human. Jesse Eisenberg wisely gives him the space he needs to dominate the screen, but never at the expense of the quieter, more reflective moments that define David's arc.

The film's pace is tight, its 90-minute running time ensuring that every scene has its purpose. From the somber tour of the Majdanek concentration camp to moments of awkward hilarity at group dinners, A Real Pain is a model of tonal balance. The soundtrack, based notably on Chopin-inspired music, weaves its way through the film, underscoring themes of loss and resilience while anchoring the narrative in its Polish setting. Cinematographer Michal Dymek captures both the beauty and darkness of the landscape, reflecting the emotional terrain the characters navigate.

What sets A Real Pain apart from other films exploring similar themes is its refusal to offer easy resolutions. Benji and David's relationship evolves, but Jesse Eisenberg resists the temptation to tie their journey to a well-defined arc. Instead, the film ends on a note of quiet ambiguity, acknowledging that the wounds of the past - both personal and collective - never fully heal. This refusal of simple catharsis is not only honest, but also deeply respectful of the film's weighty subject matter.

With A Real Pain, Jesse Eisenberg has created a work that is as intellectually stimulating as it is emotionally moving. It's a film that lingers, inviting reflection long after the credits have rolled. At once a deeply personal project and a universally relevant story, it confirms Eisenberg's place as a filmmaker of remarkable insight and compassion. It's a film that makes you suffer and laugh in equal measure - a real triumph.

A Real Pain
Written and directed by Jesse Eisenberg
Produced by Ewa Puszczyńska, Jennifer Semler, Jesse Eisenberg, Emma Stone, Ali Herting, Dave McCary
Starring Jesse Eisenberg, Kieran Culkin, Will Sharpe, Jennifer Grey, Kurt Egyiawan, Liza Sadovy, Daniel Oreskes
Cinematography : Michał Dymek
Edited by Robert Nassau
Production companies: Topic Studios, Fruit Tree, Rego Park, , Extreme Emotions
Distributed by Searchlight Pictures (United States), The Walt Disney Company (France)
Release dates : January 20, 2024 (Sundance), November 1, 2024 (United States), February 26 2025 (France)
Running time : 90 minutes

Viewed on January 3, 2025 on VOD

Mulder's Mark: