Dear Santa

Dear Santa is an end-of-year comedy full of potential, combining an inspired premise with a cast and crew renowned for their ability to blend irreverent humor with heartfelt storytelling. Directed by Bobby Farrelly and co-written by Peter Farrelly and Ricky Blitt, the film reunites the Farrelly brothers with Jack Black, marking their first collaboration since 2001's Shallow Hal. Despite its plot and flashes of talent, Dear Santa stumbles, weighed down by tonal inconsistencies, a disappointing narrative and an inability to fully capitalize on its darkly comic premise.

Basically, the film hinges on a clever scenario: What if a child's dyslexia led him to mistakenly address a Christmas letter to Satan instead of Santa? The result is an unexpected holiday guest: the Prince of Darkness himself, played by Jack Black with a mixture of cheerful charm and restrained menace. Black's arrival sets the stage for a series of antics: he offers 11-year-old Liam Turner (Robert Timothy Smith) three wishes, knowing that granting each one will cost him his soul. This situation is ripe for comedy, moral dilemmas and the subversion of typical holiday clichés. Unfortunately, the film rarely lives up to its promise.

The film's most successful moments come from its protagonists. Jack Black's portrayal of Satan is a curious blend of playfulness and charisma, drawing heavily on his well-established comic persona. Whether he's delivering deadpan lines, reveling in his antics or playing the role of diabolical mentor, Black infuses his character with enough energy to keep viewers interested. His Satan is less a terrifying figure of evil than an awkward, sometimes lovable anti-hero, a choice that favors the family tone while limiting the character's narrative potential.

Opposite Black, Robert Timothy Smith delivers a remarkable performance as Liam. The young actor brings a natural charm to the role, balancing Liam's vulnerability as a dyslexic social outcast with his determination to resist Satan's temptations. Liam's struggles - navigating his parents' crumbling marriage, dealing with bullies and pining for his love Emma (Kai Cech) - anchor the film in a realistic, if clichéd, coming-of-age story. Her dynamic with Black forms the film's emotional core, though it never quite transcends the superficial exploration of their bond.

Dear Santa's main weakness lies in its inability to adopt a consistent tone. The Farrelly brothers have built their careers on a combination of wry humor and heartfelt storytelling, but here the balance is off. The film oscillates between juvenile gags - such as Satan causing explosive diarrhea in Liam's obnoxious teacher, Mr. Charles (P.J. Byrne) - and sincere attempts at family drama, such as the lingering grief over a past tragedy that haunts Liam's parents, Molly (Brianne Howey) and Bill (Hayes MacArthur). The result is a film that's unsure of its audience, too crude for young viewers, but too superficial for adults looking for sharper satire.

The screenplay, co-written by Peter Farrelly and Ricky Blitt, exacerbates these problems. While it occasionally contains amusing pop culture references - Satan's joke about staying at the “Redrum Motor Lodge” is a highlight - it often relies on hackneyed clichés and lazy humor. The decision to set an important part of the film during a Post Malone concert, with an extended cameo by the artist, looks like a miscalculation. Although it allows Liam to impress his crush, the sequence is too long and contributes little to the overall narrative.

Dear Santa's central premise - a child grappling with the moral and practical consequences of his relationship with Satan - offers rich thematic potential. How can an innocent soul cope with the lure of selfish desires? How does Satan reconcile his own nature with the genuine goodness of a child? Unfortunately, the film sidesteps these questions, opting instead for low-stakes wish fulfillment and predictable holiday tropes.

Liam's three wishes, for example, are disappointingly uninspired. His first wish, to take Emma to the aforementioned concert, feels more like a vehicle for celebrity cameos than a meaningful narrative choice. Subsequent wishes also lack creativity, and the film's final resolution relies on an overly saccharine twist that undermines its darker overtones. The lack of inventive or challenging storylines for Liam and Satan gives the film a superficial feel, a missed opportunity given its ambitious concept.

The supporting cast, while competent, struggles to leave a lasting impression. Brianne Howey and Hayes MacArthur deliver acceptable performances as Liam's bickering parents, but their characters are little more than figureheads in a generic domestic drama. Keegan-Michael Key, as child psychologist Dr. Finkleman, injects brief moments of humor with his deadpan voice, but his role is too small to have any meaningful impact.

Liam's friendship with Gibby (Jaden Carson Baker), another social outcast, offers some of the film's most authentic moments. Their camaraderie adds depth to Liam's character, although Gibby's subplot - pretending to have cancer as part of a misguided scheme - seems unnecessary and poorly handled. These subplots clutter the narrative without adding significant stakes or developments.

Visually, Dear Santa is acceptable but unremarkable. Bobby Farrelly's direction lacks the energy and inventiveness that characterized the brothers' early work. The production design, particularly Satan's burgundy leather and fur ensemble, adds a touch of flair, but the film's overall aesthetic feels generic. Even the Christmas elements, which should evoke warmth and nostalgia, come across as superficial rather than magical.

Dear Santa is a film that wastes its potential. The combined talents of Jack Black and the Farrelly brothers, along with a concept conducive to dark comedy, should have produced a holiday classic. Instead, the film resembles a patchwork of missed opportunities, tonal errors and half-baked ideas. While it offers moments of charm and humor - thanks in large part to its actors - it fails to leave a lasting impression.

For Jack Black fans, there's enough here to warrant an occasional viewing, especially for those looking for light entertainment for the festive season. But for those hoping for a film that challenges convention or delivers on the promise of its devilishly clever premise, Dear Santa is likely to disappoint. It's a film that tries to be both good and bad, but is ultimately neither, a forgettable addition to the ever-growing catalog of Christmas comedies.

Dear Santa
Directed by Bobby Farrelly
Written by Ricky Blitt, Peter Farrelly
Story by Ricky Blitt, Peter Farrelly, Dan Ewen
Produced by Bobby Farrelly, Peter Farrelly, Jeremy Kramer
Starring Jack Black, Keegan-Michael Key, Robert Timothy Smith, Brianne Howey, Hayes MacArthur, Austin Post, P. J. Byrne
Cinematography : C. Kim Miles
Edited by Julie Garcés
Music by Rupert Gregson-Williams
Production companies: Conundrum Entertainment, Farrelly Brothers, Kraymotion Films
Distributed by Paramount Pictures
Release date : November 25, 2024 (United States), December 18, 2024 (France)
Running time : 103 minutes

Viewed: November 28, 2024 (Paramount+ press Screener)

Mulder's Mark: