Caddo Lake

Caddo Lake is a captivating, atmospheric thriller that blends elements of mystery, science fiction and emotional family drama, while exploring deep-rooted generational trauma. Written and directed by Celine Held and Logan George, the film uses the haunting beauty of its setting, Caddo Lake, to weave two parallel stories filled with tension, loss and the uncanny sense that something supernatural might be lurking beneath the surface.

The film follows two main characters, Paris, played by Dylan O'Brien, and Ellie, played by Eliza Scanlen. Paris is a young man recovering from the tragic death of his mother in a car accident that plunged them into the waters of Caddo Lake. He remains traumatized and detached from those around him, including his father, played by Sam Hennings, and his girlfriend, Cee, played by Diana Hopper. Paris isolates himself, living with unshakeable guilt and a fixation on the idea that there might be something extraterrestrial linked to his mother's illness and death.

On the other side of the story, Ellie, a fiercely independent and rebellious teenager, struggles with her own fractured family life. Eliza Scanlen powerfully plays Ellie, whose strained relationship with her mother, Celeste, played by Lauren Ambrose, and stepfather, Daniel, played by Eric Lange, forms the emotional backbone of her story. The disappearance of her beloved half-sister, Anna, played by Caroline Falk, triggers a series of mysterious and unsettling events that force Ellie to delve into her family's past and confront the secrets that surround Caddo Lake.

From the outset, Celine Held and Logan George create a visually immersive world that immediately draws the audience into the eerie, mystical landscape of the bayou. The lake, with its flooded cypress trees draped in Spanish moss, serves not only as a backdrop, but also as a living presence in the film. Lowell A. Meyer's cinematography Meyer's cinematography captures the beauty and danger of this setting, creating a labyrinthine atmosphere where every turn on the water seems both familiar and unsettling. This sense of foreboding is reinforced by David Baloche's dark, ominous score, which completes the film's tone and maintains the tension throughout.

Caddo Lake stands out for the way it interweaves two seemingly separate stories into a coherent narrative that gradually reveals how Paris and Ellie's lives are intertwined. Both characters are plagued by grief and loss, but they approach these emotions in different ways. Dylan O'Brien delivers an understated, introspective performance as Paris, who is consumed by guilt and obsessed with his mother's death. His character is quieter, more passive, and this often makes his plot feel underdeveloped compared to Ellie's more dynamic arc. Nevertheless, O'Brien brings a vulnerability to Paris that makes her emotional journey resonate, especially as the story progresses.

Eliza Scanlen, meanwhile, is the film's emotional anchor. Her portrayal of Ellie is both raw and provocative, showing a teenager desperate to discover the truth about her family and the lake. Her interactions with Celeste, played by Lauren Ambrose, a grief-stricken mother struggling to hold her family together, are among the film's most fascinating moments. Lauren Ambrose, known for her work in Servant, a series also directed by Céline Held and Logan George under the direction of M. Night Shyamalan, shines in this role. She brings a complex emotional depth to Celeste, whose volatility and strained relationship with Ellie are at the root of much of the film's family drama.

The disappearance of Anna, played by Caroline Falk, is the catalyst for much of the film's mystery. As Ellie embarks on her journey to discover what has happened to her half-sister, the story becomes increasingly rich in intrigue and suspense. The filmmakers skillfully build tension with subtle clues and red herrings, creating a complex web of secrets that slowly unravels as the story progresses. The pace of the story is deliberately slow, allowing the audience to absorb the details of each character's emotional state and the mysteries surrounding Caddo Lake.

However, while the film excels in world-building and visual storytelling, there are moments when the dual narrative structure falters. Paris' story, though emotionally charged, doesn't have the same intensity or stakes as Ellie's. Although Dylan O'Brien effectively portrays Paris's inner turmoil, his character is largely defined by the grief caused by his mother's death, which limits the development of his arc. Ellie's journey is far more interesting, particularly as she confronts her complicated relationship with her mother and deals with the growing tensions within her family. The imbalance between the two plots sometimes causes pacing problems, especially when the story returns to Paris.

Despite these minor drawbacks, Céline Held and Logan George demonstrate an impressive ability to maintain suspense and mystery throughout the film. Their direction is meticulous, and they deftly integrate elements of science fiction and supernatural intrigue without over-explaining the story's central mysteries. The film's sinister atmosphere is enhanced by the cinematography and production design, which make the bayou a character in its own right, a place filled with dark secrets waiting to be discovered.

Supporting actors, notably Eric Lange as the well-meaning stepfather, Daniel, and Sam Hennings as Paris's ailing father, add depth to the family dynamics at the film's emotional heart. Strained relationships between parents and children are a recurring theme in Caddo Lake, and the filmmakers treat these dynamics with subtlety and care. The performances of all the actors are excellent, with Lauren Ambrose and Eliza Scanlen standing out in particular for their emotionally-charged interactions.

One of the most intriguing aspects of the film is the way Celine Held and Logan George incorporate elements of science fiction and supernatural mystery without losing sight of the emotional core of the story. The directors are clearly influenced by their work on M. Night Shyamalan's Servant, and his presence as producer on Caddo Lake is felt in the film's twisting narrative and unexpected revelations. Although the sci-fi elements are not fully explained, they add a layer of complexity to the film that keeps the audience's attention, even when the story takes unexpected turns.

The film's conclusion, while not entirely emotionally satisfying, nevertheless manages to bring the various narrative threads together in a way that feels coherent. The mystery at the heart of Caddo Lake is captivating, and the final act offers enough surprises to keep viewers interested. However, the film's emotional resolution, particularly in the Paris story, feels somewhat rushed and underdeveloped compared to the meticulous construction of the previous acts.

Caddo Lake is a film that excels in its atmosphere and visual storytelling, even if character development and pacing are sometimes uneven. Celine Held and Logan George have created a haunting, slow-burning thriller that will leave audiences pondering its mysteries long after the credits roll. Thanks to strong performances from Eliza Scanlen, Dylan O'Brien and Lauren Ambrose, the film manages to balance its complex plot with emotionally powerful moments, even if it fails to achieve all the emotional goals it has set itself.

Caddo Lake is a very successful second film for Celine Held and Logan George, and it's clear that they have a bright future ahead of them as filmmakers. The film's exploration of grief, family and the supernatural, all set against the spellbinding backdrop of the bayou, makes it captivating and memorable.

Caddo Lake
Written and directed by Celine Held, Logan George
Produced by M. Night Shyamalan, Ashwin Rajan, Kara Durrett, Josh Godfrey
Starring Dylan O'Brien, Eliza Scanlen, Lauren Ambrose, Eric Lange, Sam Hennings
Production companies : New Line Cinema, Blinding Edge Pictures, K Period Media[1]
Distributed by Max
Release date : October 10, 2024
Running time : 99 minutes

Viewed on September 30, 2024 (Max screener press)

Mulder's Mark: