The strangers’ case

The Strangers' Case is the feature debut of American producer and director Brandt Andersen. It is a poignant exploration of the global refugee crisis through personal stories that cross borders, cultures and, inevitably, moral boundaries. Tackling the sensitive subject of the Syrian civil war and its aftermath, the film is a bold attempt to convey the desperation and resilience of those caught up in one of the most devastating humanitarian crises of our time. However, while the film's intentions are clear, the execution sometimes seems too calculated, leaving audiences with mixed feelings about its effectiveness.

The narrative structure of The Strangers' Case is both its strength and its weakness. Brandt Andersen uses a chaptered format, with each segment focusing on different characters whose lives intersect as a result of the war in Syria. The central figure is Amira, played by Yasmine Al Massri, a Syrian doctor whose journey from the bombed-out streets of Aleppo to the relative safety of a hospital in Chicago forms the emotional backbone of the film. Yasmine Al Massri delivers a powerful performance, portraying Amira's unyielding strength and vulnerability as she navigates the horrors of war while trying to protect her daughter, Rasha, played by Massa Daoud. The film's prologue and epilogue, set in Chicago, give the impression of coming full circle, which, while neat, detracts 
somewhat from the rawness of the narrative.

The film's depiction of the refugee experience is undeniably heartbreaking, particularly in scenes like the one where Amira's family home is destroyed, forcing her and Rasha to flee. This narrative is echoed in the stories of other characters, such as Mustafa, a conflicted Syrian soldier played by Yahya Mahayni, and Marwan, a morally ambiguous human smuggler played by Omar Sy. These characters are drawn in broad strokes, each representing different facets of the refugee crisis - Yahya Mahayni's Mustafa grapples with his internal struggle between duty and conscience, and Omar Sy's Marwan exploits the refugees' desperation while nurturing his own dreams of a better life for his son.

Despite these captivating character arcs, the film sometimes fails in its attempts to emotionally connect the audience with its protagonists. The sense of urgency and despair is palpable, but Brandt Andersen's directorial choices sometimes seem too artificial to elicit a specific reaction from the viewer. The film is replete with moments clearly designed to strike a chord, such as the tragic separation of families or the innocence of children caught in the crossfire. However, these moments are so carefully crafted that they risk coming across as manipulative rather than authentic.

The film's production design, directed by Julie Berghoff, deserves special mention. The recreated scenes of Aleppo are strikingly realistic, immersing the viewer in the chaos and destruction of a war-torn city. Jonathan Sela's sound design and cinematography also contribute to the film's immersive quality, particularly in the tension-filled sequences set on the turbulent waters of the Mediterranean, where the lives of the refugees hang in the balance.
Yet for all its technical prowess, The Strangers' Case is sometimes undermined by its own ambition. Brandt Andersen's screenplay, which draws heavily on real events and tragedies, seems weighed down by its didacticism. 

The film often blurs the line between art and activism, Andersen seeming more inclined to deliver a message than tell a nuanced story. This is particularly evident in the dialogue, which sometimes slips into moralistic discourse. For example, when a child's plea - “Please don't leave me again, Daddy” - foreshadows impending disaster, it seems more like a narrative device than a genuine moment of despair.

The film's title, The Strangers' Case, is a nod to a speech in William Shakespeare's play Sir Thomas More, which defends the rights of refugees and condemns the inhumanity to which they are subjected. This literary reference underlines the film's thematic concerns and lends it a certain gravity. However, it also highlights the film's difficulty in striking a balance between its lofty ambitions and the more down-to-earth demands of storytelling.

The Strangers' Case is as fascinating as it is frustrating. It's a well-meaning, visually appealing work that highlights an urgent global problem, but it's also a film that occasionally stumbles over its own sincerity. Although the performances, particularly those of Yasmine Al Massri and Yahya Mahayni, are commendable and the production values first-rate, the film's over-reliance on melodrama and its somewhat mechanical narrative structure prevent it from having the emotional impact it so desperately seeks. Brandt Andersen's debut film is certainly worth seeing, but it leaves the lingering feeling that it could have been so much more.

The strangers' case
Written and directed by Brandt Andersen
Produced by Brandt Andersen, Ossama Bawardi, Ryan Busse & Charlie Endean
Starring Yasmine Al Massri, Yahya Mahayni, Omar Sy, Ziad Bakri, Constantine Markoulakis, Jason Beghe
Music: Nick Chuba
Director of photography: Jonathan Sela
Editing: Jeff Seibeneck
Production companies: The Reel Foundation, Karma Film Prod, Philistine Films, SPACE + ART Entertainment
Distributed by : NC
Release date: NC
Running time: 97 minutes

Screened on September 7, 2024 at the Centre International de Deauville

Mulder's Mark: