Exhibiting forgiveness

Titus Kaphar's debut feature, Exhibiting Forgiveness , is a film that lingers long after the credits have rolled, leaving the viewer with an emotional weight both profound and unsettling. The film, which premiered at the Sundance Film Festival 2024, explores in depth the complexities of forgiveness, generational trauma and the weight of the past, through the prism of a black family struggling to reconcile its painful history.

The story centers on Tarrell, played with gripping intensity by André Holland, a successful painter who is haunted by memories of his abusive father, La'Ron, played by John Earl Jelks. These memories manifest themselves in vivid nightmares, which not only disrupt his life, but also fuel his deeply personal art. Tarrell's journey is marked by internal conflict, as he wonders whether he should forgive a man who has caused him so much pain, even as his mother, Joyce, played by the ever-convincing Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor, urges him to do so through the prism of her religious faith.

Titus Kaphar, a renowned artist who moves on to direct, brings a unique visual style to the film that is both striking and intimate. His experience as a painter is evident in the way he constructs scenes, often framing them as if they were living canvases. The film's credits, which blend seamlessly with the walls of the art studio, set the tone for a narrative in which every frame seems to be a work of art in itself. This attention to detail not only reinforces the emotional depth of the story, but also underscores the film's central theme: the intersection of art and personal healing.

The film's structure, which oscillates between present-day interactions and flashbacks to Tarrell's traumatic childhood, is expertly handled. These transitions are never abrupt but occur naturally, reflecting the way in which past traumas can invade the present. The flashbacks are particularly harrowing, revealing the extent of La'Ron's abuse and the scars it has left on Tarrell. Yet Titus Kaphar wisely avoids turning these scenes into mere spectacle. Instead, they are rooted in the raw emotional reality of the characters' experiences, allowing the viewer to feel the weight of each moment.

The actors' performances are simply outstanding. André Holland brilliantly plays Tarrell, a man caught between love for his family and unresolved anger towards his father. Holland's ability to convey deep pain and vulnerability, often without saying a word, is a testament to his talent as an actor. His interactions with Jelks' La'Ron are particularly electric, filled with a tension that speaks volumes about the unresolved issues between them.

John Earl Jelks, as La'Ron, offers a portrait both haunting and sympathetic. While it would be easy to portray La'Ron as a one-dimensional villain, Jelks imbues the character with a complexity that makes his struggle for redemption both believable and tragic. His performance captures the essence of a man who is both victim and perpetrator, shaped by his own abusive upbringing and desperate to find some semblance of peace.

Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor, as Joyce, forms the emotional core of the film. Her portrayal of a mother who forgives out of necessity, even denial, adds a new layer of complexity to the story. Joyce's unwavering faith and ability to forgive La'Ron, despite everything, is both admirable and frustrating, reflecting the internal conflict many viewers might feel about forgiveness.

Exhibiting Forgiveness is a film that offers no easy answers. The title itself suggests a duality: on the one hand, forgiveness as a concept is exposed, examined from every angle, and on the other, it poses the question of whether true forgiveness is really possible. Titus Kaphar resists the urge to fictionalize the story, instead presenting a narrative as messy and complicated as the emotions it explores.

Religion plays an important role in the film, particularly in the way it intertwines with the theme of forgiveness. Joyce's faith is both her anchor and her blind spot, driving her to encourage reconciliation even if it's not in Tarrell's best interests. This tension between religious forgiveness and personal healing is handled with care, avoiding didacticism and instead inviting the viewer to wrestle with these issues alongside the characters.
The climax of the film, which takes place during an exhibition of Tarrell's latest works, puts these themes to the test. As wealthy patrons admire his art, oblivious to the pain that underlies it, Tarrell is forced to confront the commodification of his trauma. This scene is both powerful and poignant, highlighting the often exploitative nature of the art world and the personal toll it takes on the artist.

Exhibiting Forgiveness is a triumph of storytelling, a film that explores the complexities of human relationships with honesty and empathy. Titus Kaphar's debut film is a deeply personal work, unafraid to confront the harsh realities of life while holding out hope for healing. This film will make you think about your own relationships, your ability to forgive, and how the past continues to shape the present. It's a film that will resonate deeply with anyone who has ever struggled with forgiveness, making it not only one of the highlights of Sundance 2024, but an important cinematic achievement in its own right.

Exhibiting forgiveness
Directed by Titus Kaphar
Produced by Stephanie Allain, Derek Cianfrance, Jamie Patricof, Titus Kaphar & Sean Cotton
Written by Titus Kaphar
With André Holland, John Earl Jelks, Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor, Andra Day
Music: Jherek Bischoff
Director of photography: Lachlan Milne
Editing: Ron Patane
Production companies: Homegrown Pictures, Shade Pictures, Hunting Lane Films
Distributed by Roadside Attractions (USA)
Release date: October 18, 2024 (U.S.)
Running time: 112 minutes

Seen on September 8, 2024 at the Deauville International Center

Mulder's Mark: