Maybe I Do

In the realm of romantic comedies, Maybe I Do presents itself as a promising venture with director Michael Jacobs at the helm and an ensemble cast featuring heavyweights like Diane Keaton, Richard Gere, Susan Sarandon, and William H. Macy. However, despite the cinematic pedigree of its cast, the film falls short of delivering a memorable exploration of relationships, leaving audiences with a forgettable experience that fails to capitalize on its star-studded potential.

At the heart of the film is a narrative that revolves around a young couple, portrayed by Emma Roberts and Luke Bracey, as they grapple with the idea of marriage. Concurrently, the film delves into the lives of their respective parents, played by the seasoned quartet of Keaton, Gere, Sarandon, and Macy. While the film attempts to dissect the complexities of relationships at different life stages, it struggles to provide the depth and authenticity required for a satisfying exploration.

One of the film's major pitfalls lies in its script, which, despite moments of absurdist sparkle and emotional nuance, hesitates to let characters engage in genuine, meaningful conversations about their relationship struggles. Instead, the audience is presented with monologues that lack the depth needed to fully understand and empathize with the characters.

Emma Roberts and Luke Bracey, who previously demonstrated chemistry in Holidate, are unfortunately given shallow characters in Maybe I Do. Their storyline, centered around a sudden discussion about marriage, feels contrived, leaving audiences yearning for more substance in the portrayal of their characters.

The star power of Diane Keaton, Richard Gere, Susan Sarandon, and William H Macy does manage to inject some life into the film. Gere, in particular, stands out with his portrayal, bringing warmth and tenderness to his role and adding a frisson to the overall atmosphere. However, even their seasoned performances can only do so much to salvage a script that shies away from delving into the complexities of mature relationships.

Despite attempts at humor and chaotic dysfunction during a group dinner scene, the film's execution feels too schematic and talky. Characters are reduced to one or two characteristics, making it challenging for the audience to empathize with their struggles. Sarandon's character, in particular, comes across as one-dimensional and mean-spirited, diminishing the impact of her attempted redemption.

Maybe I Do is further hindered by its dated conceits and theatrical roots. The film's reluctance to explore the depth of its characters and their relationships, coupled with a lackluster portrayal of the younger couple, makes it a forgettable entry in the romantic comedy genre. For viewers seeking a more satisfying exploration of mature relationships, there are undoubtedly better options available.

While the film does have its moments and benefits from a seasoned cast, it ultimately fails to rise above its mediocrity. The disjointed editing, lack of chemistry among the cast, and antiquated dialogue contribute to the film's overall shortcomings. Maybe I Do becomes a cautionary tale about the perils of investing one's identity solely in romantic relationships, leaving audiences longing for a more meaningful and nuanced cinematic experience from such a celebrated ensemble.

Maybe I Do
Written and directed by Michael Jacobs
Based on Cheaters by Michael Jacobs
Produced by Vincent Newman, Michael Jacobs, Scott Mednick
Starring  Diane Keaton, Richard Gere, Susan Sarandon, Emma Roberts, Luke Bracey, William H. Macy
Cinematography : Tim Suhrstedt
Edited by Erica Freed Marker
Music by Lesley Barber
Production companies : Fifth Season, Vincent Newman Entertainment
Distributed by Vertical Entertainment (United States), Paramount+ (France)
Release date : January 25, 2023 (United States), December 15, 2023 (Frace)
Running time : 95 minutes

Viewed December 15, 2023 (Paramount+)

Mulder's Mark: